This week I finally got a chance to see “Earth”, the first film from Disney’s new independent label dedicated to nature documentaries called Disneynature. It is a visually breathtaking film, and the label itself is a terrific idea moving forward. But “Earth” did not meet the level of expectations that I had for it.
“Earth” begins with incredible sweeping landscape shots that leave your jaw on the floor. Like the television documentary, the film relies heavily on time-lapse landscape scenes to offer an insightful view into how our planet works. Kids and adults alike will be astonished. But it isn’t all just visual eye candy. There is also something of a story to this film.

What Disneynature has attempted to do with “Earth”, keeping with the great tradition of Walt Disney’s True Life Adventures, is to bring all of this incredible footage into three separate stories about three different families struggling for survival in a harsh natural world. We meet ridiculously cute polar bear cubs learning to walk on the ice and snow for the first time, a baby elephant who, like many of our own little ones, struggles to keep pace with an adult world, and a mother and baby humpback whale traveling thousands of miles for food. Some succeed in their struggle and some don’t. The question I have is whether or not kids, or even adults, will find it upsetting. Yes, I know that it is an accurate reflection of the “Circle of Life”, but that doesn’t make it any easier to watch.
For instance, throughout the film we follow a Polar Bear male who we are told is the father of the two cubs. Near the very end of the film we watch this “father” struggle to find food and then eventually starve to death as a result of injuries inflicted while trying to hunt walruses. The entire sequence, from the fights with the walruses, to the slow painful death of the bear is something I would not want my kids to have to see if they are at all sensitive. It is a difficult scene for anyone to watch. Honestly, my own wife would be crying if she saw it!
In fairness to Disney, they have done their best to keep and blood or gore out of this film. But they still need to be more sensitive to the audience they seek. In future films, if they are going to market them towards families, they should try and keep the melancholy out of it. Being just about the last sequence in the film, the dying Polar Bear is about all most will remember. And that is what will ruin this film for many people.

The first thought that came through my mind was “are they really going to roll a camera and watch this bear die? Is there nothing they can do to help? No rescue organization to call?” Now that may all be irrational, but the point is, imagine what a child would think? As you can plainly tell the scene upset me, even though I had seen it before on television. But I am an adult. I can see the important message of how fragile even this giant and ferocious bear’s life really is. But I doubt a child can.
I know this is what happens in the wild, and I expect to see this when watching Animal Planet or PBS. But this is something Disney is producing and we expect to have a film everyone can watch and enjoy as a result of the Disney name. Couldn’t we get perhaps a more “family friendly” version of the television series? This one sequence turned a family friendly film into a real-life drama of life and death, and I am not sure that is what they wanted or what parents will want. While other scenes are also tough, this one sequence, seeing a very endangered bear die slowly and painfully was totally unnecessary in this the supposed “family friendly” version of this footage.
The film was shot by the same British crew that shot the popular Discovery Channel miniseries called “Planet Earth” which aired back in 2007. No matter what you may read about how much new footage was in this film, I believe Disney says only 30 percent of the footage is old, you can’t help but think this is just a shorter version of the miniseries. While some footage may have been new, many of what I would call the “signature scenes” that made “Planet Earth” famous are here. The Mandarin Duck chicks leaping from their nest high in a tree and bouncing on the ground, Great White Sharks flying out of the water to catch seals, lions chasing down an elephant at night, and even the Polar Bear death sequence are all major portions of the television program. While their may be lots of new footage here, there was certainly more than enough very noticeable old stuff to make you wonder how new this film really is.
Having said all that, I suppose I would recommend this film to adults who either never saw “Planet Earth” or did and enjoyed it. The narration and music in the movie far surpasses that of the television series, and the visuals are something truly to behold on the big screen. But I can assure you I won’t be watching it again. For future films, and Disneynature has a film called “Oceans” coming out on Earth Day 2010, I would advise the filmmakers to do all they can to try and show the real world but to keep in mind that Disney will market this film to children.